Role of time pressure on dentists’ diagnostic decision making

How well do you perform under time pressure? 

Previous research suggests that dentists experience stress in their working lives, and time pressure is one of the most frequently cited stressor factors. There is conflicting evidence in the medical literature on how this time pressure may affect doctor’s diagnostic and treatment decisions. However, there is no published research in which the performance of dentists under stress, including time pressure, has been evaluated.

To address this gap in the literature, we conducted a research study aiming to explore the impact of time pressure on dentists’ diagnostic performance when viewing dental radiographs. Our study demonstrated a significant deterioration of dentists' diagnostic performance under time-pressure when examining bitewing radiographs. Diagnostic errors may put patient safety at risk, with patients potentially being harmed if pathology is missed. Such errors can have medicolegal implications on the dentists' practice.

 

Description of the study and summary of results


Forty dentists were randomised to examine and provide a radiographic report on two sets of radiographs (six bitewings in each set) under two conditions on a cross-over basis: time-pressure vs. no-time-pressure. The radiographic report of an experienced consultant was considered the gold standard against which participants diagnostic decisions were compared to calculate sensitivity and specificity. Participants rated their stress after each experimental condition using a 100 mm visual analogue scale (VAS).

The VAS scores for stress were significantly higher in the time pressure condition vs. no time pressure condition (mean: 55.78 versus 10.73, p < 0.0001), indicating that the time pressure acted as a source of stress. Dentists' diagnostic performance was affected; the sensitivity was significantly lower under time pressure (median: 0.50 versus 0.80, p < 0.0001), but by contrast, the median diagnostic specificity was 1.00 under both conditions.

Our study concluded that time pressure negatively impacts one aspect of dentists' diagnostic performance, namely sensitivity (increased diagnostic errors and omissions of pathology), which can potentially affect patient safety and the quality of care delivered. However, time pressure was found to have less influence on diagnostic specificity.

The study has been published in the Journal of Dentistry.

About the researcher 

Anastasios Plessas 

Academic Clinical Fellow in Primary Dental Care Plymouth University Peninsula Schools of Medicine and Dentistry

I am a dentist currently undertaking a research master’s degree about the impact of stress on the practice of dentistry.

My supervisors were: