Future ocean conditions could cause significant changes in marine mussels

The increased temperature and acidification of our oceans over the next century have been argued to cause significant physical changes in an economically important marine species.

Scientists from the University of Plymouth exposed blue mussels (Mytilus edulis) to current and future levels of ocean acidification (OA) or warming (W), as well as both together – commonly known as OAW.

Initial comparison of mussel shells showed that warming alone led to increased shell growth, but increasing warming and acidification led to decreased shell growth indicating that OA was dissolving their shells.

However, analysis using cutting edge electron microscopy of the shell crystal matrix or 'ultrastructure' revealed that, in fact, warming alone has the potential to significantly alter the physical properties of the mussels’ shells, whereas acidification mitigated some of the negative effects.

Mussels grown under warming exhibited changes in their crystal structures including a propensity for increased brittleness, which would place mussels under greater threat from their many predators including crabs and starfish.

These negative effects were to some degree mitigated under acidified conditions with mussel shells showing evidence of repair, even though their crystals grew differently to the norm.

The study, published in a Frontiers of Marine Science special issue titled Global Change and the Future Ocean, is the latest research by the University into the potential effects of ocean warming and acidification on marine species.

Previous projects have suggested future conditions could significantly reduce the nutritional qualities of oysters as well as dissolving the shells of sea snails and reducing their overall size by around a third.

<p>Square crop -&nbsp;

A microscopic image (2500x) of a mussel shell grown in current climate conditions, showing regular crystals and layers

</p>
A microscopic image (2500x) of a mussel shell grown in current climate conditions, showing regular crystals and layers
<p>square crop -&nbsp;A microscopic image (2500x) of a mussel shell grown in predicted future climate conditions, showing the shell’s composition disordered and fragmented (Credit University of Plymouth</p>
A microscopic image (2500x) of a mussel shell grown in predicted future climate conditions, showing the shell’s composition disordered and fragmented

Dr Antony Knights, Associate Professor in Marine Ecology and the study’s lead author, said:

“By the end of the century, we are predicted to see increases in sea surface temperature of 2-4°C and at least a doubling of atmospheric CO2. It is no surprise that would have an effect on marine species, but this research is surprising in that acidification appears to mitigate changes in shell structure attributable to rising sea temperatures, which is counter to what we would have predicted. It may be that increased CO2 in the water is providing more 'raw material' for the mussels to repair their shells that is not available under just warming conditions.”

Dr Natasha Stephen, Director of Plymouth Electron Microscopy Centre, added:

“Until now, there have been relatively few studies assessing the combined effects of ocean acidification and warming on shell structures. However, understanding the changes that might result at a microscopic level may provide important insights in to how organisms will respond to future climate change. This study shows it can certainly have negative effects but also that they are not always predictable, which presents some serious challenges when it comes to trying to disentangle the consequences of climate change.”

The full study – Knights et al: Ocean acidification mitigates the negative effects of increased sea temperatures on the biomineralisation and crystalline ultrastructure of Mytilus – is published in Frontiers of Marine Science, doi: 10.3389/fmars.2020.567228.

Read more information linked to this article

The Marine Biology and Ecology Research Centre (MBERC)

Members of the MBERC address a broad range of research questions, from the effects of environmental stress on microbes and developing embryos to the management of large scale impacts, such as global climate change.

Find out more about our research

Plymouth Electron Microscopy Centre

Our flagship facility provides access to a comprehensive suite of light microscopes, electron microscopes (EM), image processing and analysis software, plus decades of experience from our team of specialists.

We support students, researchers, academics and businesses across a range of disciplines and sectors, from engineering and advanced manufacturing to geology, textiles, planetary science and beyond. 

Find out more about our work, and how we can help you with our state-of-the-art equipment

Tackling the global ocean acidification problem

Our world-leading experts increase understanding of how climate change has forced marine organisms to adapt, working with policymakers and stakeholders to minimise and address the impacts of ocean acidification.

Find out more about our ocean acidification research