Reducing the gender and ethnicity attainment gap
Information and resources to support efforts in tackling the attainment gap
The university actively promotes an inclusive culture in teaching and learning, and it is important to ensure that we continue to reflect on the needs of our diverse student community particularly students with English as an Additional Language (EAL), black and minority ethnic groups (BME), care leavers, students with disabilities and males from lower socio–economic backgrounds (aka white working class boys (WWCB) who can be at risk of under-attainment.
While the numbers of students receiving a first or 2:1 have increased over the last 8 years, there continues to be a considerable gap between the proportion of white British students receiving these classifications compared to UK-domiciled students from minority ethnic groups (Runnymede Trust, 2015). This attainment gap has remained nearly static over the last ten years.
Jo Johnson, Minister of State for Universities and Science, in guidance to the Director of Fair Access (published in 2016) requested HEIs to set targets for students from disadvantaged backgrounds; specifically students from BME, WWCB and students with disabilities and learning difficulties.
Unpicking the black attainment gap provides up-to-date data on the black and Asian student attainment gap (Wonkhe, August 2017).
University information and learning programmes on equality, diversity and inclusion
General University information
Equality, diversity and inclusion main University pages provides links to:
- Harassment, bullying and intimidation advice for staff and students.
- Equality analysis and University of Plymouth Equality Scheme Targets.
E-Learning (staff login required):
- Equality and diversity: diversity in the workplace.
- Unconscious bias.
Relevant 7 steps series guides to help plan and teach effectively:
- Internationalising teaching and learning
- Adopting culturally inclusive teaching practices
- Mitigating unconscious bias
- Inclusive teaching and learning
- Inclusive Assessment
- Using group work in teaching
- Managing (Inter) National Research
Inclusive teaching, learning and assessment: includes research-informed resources, guidance and videos. Some of the student videos include the experience of international students.
Online self-assessment tool for University of Plymouth staff and students. This tool is available in the DLE. It evaluates students’ early engagement with learning. It provides automated feedback, helping to identify students at risk and directing them to appropriate resources and sources of support.
Use the peer review process and the Personal Development Review process to focus on equality, diversity and the attainment gap.
External guidance and resources
Race Equality Toolkit to assist staff designing for and embedding race equality in their learning and teaching. Sections of particular interest are:
- 1.2. ‘Is racism within the learning environment…swiftly addressed?’ (under ‘#1 Classroom environment’)
- 2. ‘#Meeting the needs of UK and international bilingual students’.
Equality and diversity in learning and teaching in HE: compendium of papers. Selected papers from a joint conference held by Equality Challenge Unit and the Higher Education Academy.
Widening Participation in UK Outward Student Mobility The project aim was to achieve a year-on-year increase in the number of students from disadvantaged and under-represented backgrounds who go abroad during their degree.Sandra Kerr OBE, Race Equality Director at Business in the Community welcomes the project. She says the project and its report “clearly sets out the positive influence that working, volunteering and studying abroad has on students’ academic attainment – particularly those from disadvantaged lower socio-economic backgrounds and BAME backgrounds. The report provides compelling evidence that this experience is not only potentially transformative for the students who take part, but also impacts on their earnings and access to graduate-level jobs after they leave university.
The toolkit collates case studies of good practice from universities and colleges across the UK who have worked to ensure students from these groups are supported on to mobility opportunities. It also includes a section focused on student perspectives following a series of focus groups and some highlighted case studies.
The Ethnicity Attainment Gap; pages 89-131. Research and examples of good practice from many HEIs, University of Sheffield 2016.
The Amos Bursary was set up to redress the under representation of young British men of African and Caribbean descent in higher education and in the professions. Amos provides the support to ensure each student moves from potential to performance.
Chavrimootoo,D. & Dawson, R.(2016) Learning and Unlearning Whiteness . Liverpool John Moores (PPT)
McIntosh, P. (1989) White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack. Peace & Freedom July/August 1989 pp10-12
White working class males in British higher education - Pre and post entry perspectives. Southern Universities Network. March 2017. Research and advice from nine southern universities.
- Post entry findings, page 44 (University of Portsmouth).
- Implications and recommendations, pages 60-63.
- Supporting attainment, pages 64-68.
Institutional racism in Higher Education: Building the anti-racist university: a toolkit. Funded by HEFCE, this resource was produced by the Centre for Ethnicity and Racism Studies (ERS) using the University of Leeds as a case study. The toolkit provides conceptual and methodological resources from which practitioners can select the most appropriate ones to implement in their institutions. Section four ‘anti-racist strategies’ seems particularly useful and within it, sections
- '4.3 Equal opportunities in the HEI’
- ‘4.5 Student recruitment, support and transition to employment’
- ‘4.6 Teaching and learning’
De Montfort University run the ’Dare to Be Mentored’ Scheme with an aim to reduce the black, Asian, and minority ethnic (BAME) attainment gap.
Athena SWAN: Good Practice Initiatives on gender equality
Research
Berry, J., and Loke, G. (2011) Improving the degree attainment of black and minority ethnic students. Equality Challenge Unit / The Higher Education Academy.
Cotton, D.R.E, George, R., Joyner, M. (2013) The Gender and Ethnicity Attainment Gap Research Project. Plymouth: Pedagogic Research Institute and Observatory, University of Plymouth. : A comparative analysis.
Cotton, D.R.E., Joyner, M., George R. and Cotton, P.A. (2015) Understanding the gender and ethnicity attainment gap in UK higher education. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 53(5), pp 475-486.
Gale, N. and Ward, N. (2017) LGBTQ-inclusivity in the higher education curriculum: a best practice guide. Birmingham: University of Birmingham.
Hillman, N. and Robinson, N. (2016) From Boys to Men: The underachievement of young men in higher education – and how to start tackling it. HEPI Report 84. Oxford: Higher Education Policy Institute.
Letter of Guidance from the Secretary of State for Business, Innovation and Skills and the Minister of State for Universities and Science to the Director of Fair Access, February 2016, p.14.
Miller, M. (2016) The Ethnicity Attainment Gap: Literature Review. Sheffield: The University of Sheffield, Widening Participation Research & Evaluation Unit.
Morgan, W. (nd) Ethnicity and Degree Attainment: Why the higher education section can no longer ignore the attainment gap. Power Point Presentation. London: University of East London.
Richardson, J.T.E. The under-attainment of ethnic minority students in UK higher education: what we know and what we don’t know. Journal of Further and Higher Education, 39(2), pp 278-291.
Southern Universities Network (2017) White Working Class Males in British Higher Education - Pre and post entry perspectives.
SOAS Students’ Union (2016) Degrees of Racism: a qualitative investigation into ethnicity attainment gaps at SOAS. London: School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS) Students’ Union.
Stevenson, J. (2012) Black and minority ethnic student degree retention and attainment Jacqueline Stevenson (2012). York: The Higher Education Academy.
Policy and guidance
Below is a list of polices, procedures and guidance for staff and students. This list is not exhaustive and if you need any help or advice please contact us.