Plymouth scibar talk: The "Hockey Stick" debate and human-induced global warming
  • The B-Bar, Barbican Theatre, Plymouth PL1 2NJ

Save event

One way of tackling the question of whether human-induced climate change is now clearly detectable, is by looking to the history of climate, and asking if the surface of the planet is now warmer than it has been in past centuries. 

This issue has been the subject of acrimonious debate over the last 15 years, both scientific and political. It has focused, in particular, on temperature reconstructions by Mann and others which appeared to show that the climate is now warmer, and is heating up faster, than at any time in the last 1,000 years. Their “Hockey Stick” graph has been both iconic and controversial, with critics attacking the scientific methods used and the conclusions drawn. Debates have been polarised partly because they have been politicised (especially in the US), at times “dirty” (e.g. ClimateGate) and because they have involved rival blogs which do not seek out scientific consensus. I will review the history of the debate, ask how far climate scientists should be responsive to critics outside their community and assess the difficulties of defining the limits to scientific (un)certainty.

Wikipedia's comprehensive overview of The Hockey Stick Controversy, part of the ongoing debate on climate change.

Neil is Professor of Physical Geography in Plymouth University's School of Geography, Earth and Environmental Sciences. His research interests include Holocene environmental change, diatom and stable isotope analysis and palaeolimnology (reconstruction of past in-land water environments).

PFebruary 2015N
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
26 27 28 29 30 31 1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 1

Today's events

About Plymouth scibar

Plymouth scibar is the Plymouth Branch of the British Science Association, whose aim is to encourage scientists and technologists to develop a dialogue with the public in a comfortable and accessible environment.

Scibars are NOT lectures or seminars - they ARE informal discussions for the non-scientist, the person who just wants to know more what is happening around them.

In many cases we will be discussing topics of current interest such as climate change, fish conservation, ageing, science and religion, the media’s relationship to science, alternative (non carbon) energies, nanotechnology, etc.

Plymouth scibar note

Attendance is free on the night but we suggest a contribution of £2 per person. 

The British Science Association is a voluntary organisation which relies on contributions from its audience to continue running events. All money received goes back into running similar projects in the city and wider South West region!

Event photography and video
Please be aware that some of the University of Plymouth's public events may be attended by University photographers and videographers, for capturing content to be used in University online and offline marketing and promotional materials, for example webpages, brochures or leaflets. If for whatever reason, you or a member of your group, do not wish to be photographed, please make yourself known to staff working at the event on arrival or to the photographer.